Arthrofibrosis With Joint Pain and Stiffness

Arthrofibrosis is a condition in which you have a buildup of scar tissue around a joint, usually after a traumatic injury or surgical procedure. It's especially common in the knee.

Arthrofibrosis can be debilitating, limiting your range of motion and causing substantial pain.

Arthrofibrosis is a common complication of procedures such as ACL reconstruction surgery and total knee arthroplasty (TKA). The condition is caused by inflammation and the creation of excess of scar tissue.

Your body's natural response to trauma, such as from an injury or surgery, is to make scar tissue. Some people tend to make too much, especially if they have an infection at the site or another problem that complicates healing. According to a 2019 study, that may be due to a disruption in the healing process. Essentially, your body doesn't get the message to stop the healing process even after the trauma is repaired, so it just keeps making scar tissue.

Scar tissue is dense and fibrous. When it forms in abundance, it can bind down the joint and prevent the normal range of motion.

The process also can cause your muscles and connective tissues to shorten and harden (called contractures.)

The primary symptoms of arthrofibrosis include:

• Pain, which can be severe and constant
• Stiffness
• Diminished range of motion

You may also develop:

• An inability to straighten your leg, resulting in a limp
• Swelling, redness, and heat in the joint 
• A grating sound or sensation when you move the joint (called crepitus)

Symptoms can become more debilitating than the original injury or the problem that prompted surgery, making it difficult to walk, drive, or get in and out of a chair.

When you go to the doctor with symptoms of arthrofibrosis, your doctor will generally give you a physical examination and ask about your history of injury or surgery. They'll also look at your ability to flex your knee.

To confirm the diagnosis and get a feel for the extent of the problem, you'll likely be sent for an MRI and X-ray.

According to current diagnostic criteria, arthrofibrosis can be diagnosed when the limited range of motion in the joint is permanent despite conservative treatments. However, some researchers question whether this is a valid criterion because some confirmed cases have involved minimal range-of-motion loss but have still been considerably painful and disabling.

Preventing arthrofibrosis is best accomplished with early motion following surgery. Arthrofibrosis used to be much more common after ACL surgery when doctors used to restrict patients' mobility. Now, most surgeons are instructing their patients to move the joint within hours of surgery, and that's lowered the likelihood of arthrofibrosis.

A 2019 study cautions against "aggressive" physical therapy, though, because exercise can trigger inflammation and thereby worsen the problem.

The first treatment for arthrofibrosis is rest, ice, and anti-inflammatory medications to reduce the pain and swelling. You'll likely be advised to start gentle range-of-motion exercises to increase flexibility. You may also be referred to physical therapy to improve your use of the joint.

If that doesn't solve the problem, then you have the option of two common procedures: non-surgical manipulation or surgery.

In the non-surgical option, you're put under general anesthesia and the doctor forcefully bends your leg to break up scar tissue.

The surgical option, in which the doctor goes in and removes the scar tissue, is more common. It's typically performed arthroscopically (with small incisions). Following surgery, it is important to have physical therapy to regain strength and motion as well as to prevent further formation of scar tissue.

In a review of arthrofibrosis after ACL reconstruction, it was noted that half of the patients were successfully treated without surgery, pointing to the success of nonsurgical methods when used first.