Out-Of-Network Claims and Bills From Health Insurance

If you see a doctor or other healthcare provider that is not covered by your health insurance plan, this is called "out of network", and you will have to pay a larger portion of your medical bill (or all of it) even if you have health insurance.

A health insurance form.
murat sarica / Getty Images

Most health insurance plans have a network of coverage, which means that they have an agreement with certain healthcare providers and hospitals to pay for care.

Often, the agreement is based on a discounted rate for services, and the providers must accept that rate without billing an extra amount to patients in order to remain in the network.

When you are selecting your health insurance coverage, insurance plans must provide a list of healthcare providers who accept their plans before you commit to their insurance.

Why Go Out-Of-Network?

You may make the choice to go out of network intentionally, or you might be blindsided by extra bills from an out-of-network provider who you thought was covered but was not.

Reasons you might receive an out of network bill include:

Going out of network by choice: Maybe you know your obstetrician is no longer covered by your insurance plan but you wouldn't let anyone else deliver your baby. You'll willingly pay extra because you believe that your healthcare provider's services are worth the out-of-pocket cost.

Out of network referral: Your surgeon is part of your insurance company's network, but the radiologist who read your X-ray is not, and you get a bill from the radiologist.

The network changes: You go to see the primary care doctor you've seen for years, only to find out that your healthcare provider is no longer part of your insurance plan when a much higher bill than you expected arrives.

Extra service: Your insurance reimburses for hospital expenses, but not for a private room. If a private room was the only kind available, your insurance may deny the claim, and you may be billed for it as if you didn't have insurance.

Avoid Out-Of-Network Billing

Unless you deliberately select an out-of-network service despite the cost, you don't want to be surprised by your medical bill. You can plan ahead to avoid and minimize out of network costs.

Call your insurer or go to their website to see whether your plan covers the healthcare providers and services you need. Your insurer may change coverage policies at any time, but if you get approval in writing, they may have to abide by it even if policies change afterward.

Confirm your provider is in-network: Don't just ask whether a provider "works with" your insurance. That just means they'll bill your insurance for you. If the services aren't in-network and your insurer only agrees to pay 10% of the cost, you'll be billed for the remaining 90%.

Double check every step of the way.: Don't assume anything your healthcare provider orders will be covered just because your medical professional's covered. They might order a blood test and send you to a lab in the same building, but that lab may not be covered by your health insurance.

Arrange for gap coverage ahead of time: If you need a special service that you can't get in your network, you may be able to arrange for coverage, even if the provider or facility is out of your network.

Contesting Out-Of-Network Bills

Perhaps the most frustrating aspect of out of network expenses is that there are different pricing structures for insurance companies than for individuals.

The magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) test that costs your insurance $1300 will cost you $2400 as an out of network service. The medicine you normally get for a $10 co-pay and costs your insurer $50 can costs you $120 at an out of network pharmacy.

You can take a few steps after the fact to try reducing your bill.

Complain to the insurance company first, and see if you can get your health plan to pay. You may find the description in your policy is fuzzy. Pull out all the stops to make it difficult for them to say no.

Negotiate those bills. Call the hospital or provider's billing department, tell them your bills are unaffordable, and ask if they can reduce the bill to a level you can afford. If not, ask them to put you on a payment plan.

If you can't or won't complain to the insurer, or can't or won't negotiate the bills yourself, consider finding a medical billing advocate to help you.

An advocate negotiates on your behalf. They can sometimes get unnecessary and unfair charges removed and set you up with a payment plan. You'll have to pay for their services, but you may save far more than you spend due to their knowledge of how the system works.

A Word From Verywell

Out-of-network care may be necessary if your network doesn't provide the health care you need. If this is a recurrent problem, consider changing your healthcare plan so you can get the care you want and see the healthcare providers you want to see without it costing you so much.

2 Sources
Verywell Health uses only high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. Read our editorial process to learn more about how we fact-check and keep our content accurate, reliable, and trustworthy.
  1. Rosenkrantz AB, Sadigh G, Carlos RC, Silva E, Duszak R. Out-of-pocket costs for advanced imaging across the US private insurance marketplace. J Am Coll Radiol. 2018;15(4):607-614.e1 doi:0.1016/j.jacr.2017.12.010

  2. Sadick B. How to negotiate a surprise medical bill. AARP. August 8, 2019.

Additional Reading

By Trisha Torrey
 Trisha Torrey is a patient empowerment and advocacy consultant. She has written several books about patient advocacy and how to best navigate the healthcare system.