Revision or Second Hip Replacement Surgery

Hip Prosthesis, Surgery
Amelie-Benoist / Getty Images

A revision hip replacement surgery is a surgical procedure to replace a worn out hip replacement implant. Hip replacements are among the most common procedures performed by orthopedic surgeons. This surgery is incredibly successful and has excellent results in the vast majority of patients. The problem, unfortunately, is that over time hip replacements wear out.

Hip replacements typically wear out very slowly, but the problem does progress over the years. 10 years after a hip replacement, there is a 90 percent chance the implant will be functioning well. 20 years after surgery, the chance is about 80 percent. By 25-30 years after surgery, about 50 percent of hip replacements are still working well.

Patients who wear out their prosthesis will require revision hip replacement surgery. Revision hip replacements may also be performed to manage complications such as infection of a hip replacement, hip replacement dislocation, or fractures of the bone around the hip replacement.

The number of hip revisions performed by orthopedic surgeons is growing quickly, at an estimated rate of 8-10 percent each year. Approximately 70,000 revision hip replacements are performed every year in the United States. 

As more people are choosing to have a hip replacement, especially at younger ages, the number of revision hip replacements is growing quickly.

Why Hip Replacements Wear Out

Hip replacements can wear out for a variety of reasons. The most common cause of a hip replacement wearing out is called aseptic loosening. Aseptic loosening occurs when the hip implants become loose within the bone. A loose hip implant tends to be painful and usually requires revision hip replacement. 

Other causes of a hip replacement wearing out include infection, breaking of the prosthesis, breaking of the bone around the prosthesis, and other complications. Depending on the cause of the implant failing, treatment other than revision hip replacement may be needed. For example, in the case of infection, the hip replacement may need to be removed to treat the infection, followed by the revision hip replacement months later.

Why Revisions Are Complex

Revision hip replacements are more complicated surgeries and the outcomes are not as good as the first hip replacement. Technical problems include the quality of the bone and the ability to adequately secure the revision hip replacements into position. Furthermore, removing the old hip replacement can necessitate more extensive surgery. Together, these problems often require the revision hip replacement to be much more complex. Careful planning by your orthopedic surgeon is needed to ensure he or she will be able to construct a hip that will allow you to adequately recover.

Another problem with revision hip replacement is that the surgery itself can be more complicated. Patients tend to be older, and less tolerant of long surgical procedures. The procedure is technically more difficult than primary hip replacements and the effects on the patient are more significant (longer surgery, more blood loss). Because of this, revision hip replacement must be carefully considered and planned. Involvement of general medical doctors, anesthesiologists, and the orthopedic surgeon are all important.

When to Have Revision Surgery

Only you and your orthopedic surgeon can decide when the time is right for revision hip replacement. Sometimes few symptoms are felt by the patients, but the X-rays will show a reason to consider a revision hip replacement. Other times, despite significant symptoms, your orthopedic surgeon may recommend against revision hip replacement.

We cannot underscore how complex revision hip replacement decision making can be. Not all problems with hip replacements are solved with revision surgery. Each patient must be considered on an individual basis—generalizations cannot be made in the case of revision hip replacement surgery.

If you have a hip replacement and think you may need revision surgery, you must discuss your options with your orthopedic surgeon.

A Word From Verywell

Performing a revision hip replacement surgery is a major undertaking. Because of the previous surgery, revision joint replacement is almost always a more difficult surgical procedure, typically leads to less successful outcomes, and has a higher risk of complication. The reasons for revision joint replacement are more difficult to include scar tissue, difficulty extracting implants, and the need for specialty implants used during the revision surgery. That said, when the hip replacement stops functioning normally, revision surgery is likely to be necessary to try and restore normal function to the joint.

Was this page helpful?

Article Sources

  • Nho SJ, Kymes SM, Callaghan JJ, Felson DT. "The burden of hip osteoarthritis in the United States: epidemiologic and economic considerations" J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2013;21 Suppl 1:S1-6.