10 Thyroid Mistakes Your Doctor May Be Making

Doctor comforting senior patient
Terry Vine/Blend Images

Did your doctor run a TSH test, tell you your results were normal, and send you on your way? Is your doctor doing everything possible to help you get your thyroid condition diagnosed and properly treated? You may think so, but many patients struggle with thyroid disease, continuing to experience chronic and debilitating symptoms, yet are told that there's nothing else the doctor can do to help.

The reality? Your doctor may be making some common mistakes in your diagnosis and treatment—mistakes that could be preventing you from feeling and living your best. Take a look at these ten things and make sure you don't recognize something your doctor is doing!

Focusing on the Test Numbers Instead of You and How You Feel

Many practitioners rely on the test numbers, to the exclusion of your symptoms and how you actually feel. More innovative practitioners believe that test results are only part of the equation, and your symptoms—including fatigue, weight gain, cholesterol levels, hair loss, body temperature, and depression, among others—are also a good way to gauge whether you are getting enough—or too much—thyroid medicine.

Relying on the TSH Test Instead of a Fully Panel

A TSH test is just one part of a full thyroid panel. You can have a TSH that falls in the "normal range," or is in the higher or lower end of normal, but you can actually have a thyroid problem or autoimmune thyroid disease (like Hashimoto's or Graves' disease).

A good practitioner doesn't rule out a thyroid condition solely on the basis of a TSH, but instead, runs additional tests, such as Free T4, Free T3. Thyroid antibodies can diagnose autoimmune conditions long before other blood values become abnormal. Treatment for people with antibodies can actually help forestall full-scale development of thyroid disease in some people.

Prescribing Only One Brand of Thyroid Medicine

The best thyroid drug is the thyroid drug that safely and effectively works best for you. Don't let a practitioner tell you that she or he "only prescribes" this drug or that drug. That's a sign that you have a practitioner who doesn't really understand the complex nature of thyroid disease. If one brand of levothyroxine (i.e., Synthroid, Levoxyl, Unithroid) doesn't work, your doctor should be willing to try another. And if levothyroxine doesn't work, then your doctor should be willing to try T3 (i.e., Cytomel) or natural thyroid.

Not Looking at Adrenal and Other Hormonal Issues as Part of the Picture

Even the best thyroid treatment may not work—or may not work as well as it could—if underlying adrenal and hormonal problems are not dealt with effectively. If your doctor is not looking at your adrenal and hormonal situation, then an important part of your health is being overlooked.

Not Providing Proper Information About How to Take Your Meds

Do you know about when and how to take calcium—and calcium-fortified juice—with your thyroid medicine? What about iron or vitamins with iron? What about a high-fiber diet? If you don't know about these things, your doctor isn't telling you key information that can help ensure that you're getting the most from your thyroid medicines.

Failing to Recognize Symptoms That Are Related to Thyroid Conditions

It is so common for doctors to fail to realize how connected thyroid problems are to so many symptoms. Here are just a few that are frequently overlooked:

Rushing to RAI Before Discussing Options for Hyperthyroidism/Graves' Disease

Only in the U.S. is radioactive iodine (RAI) considered a first-line treatment for hyperthyroidism and Graves' disease. While as many as 25% of patients have a chance of remission and a variety of options —including alternative medicine—to choose from, few patients will hear about them from their physicians. The solution? Learn about your options. Consider reading Elaine Moore's book Graves' Disease: A Practical Guide, or Mary Shomon's Living Well With Graves Disease' and Hyperthyroidism.

Failing to See the Bigger Picture of Autoimmune Disease

Few doctors warn Hashimoto's or Graves' disease patients that they face a higher risk of developing other autoimmune conditions such as Sjogren's Syndrome (dry eyes and mouth), or Raynaud's Syndrome (tingling, numb hands and feet) or rheumatoid arthritis (aching, painful joints and muscles). There are almost 100 different autoimmune conditions, and there are things we can do to help prevent, avoid, heal and even cure some autoimmune conditions.

Providing Little Support or Guidance for Weight Loss

Some physicians will tell you that hypothyroidism has nothing to do with weight gain and that after RAI or thyroid surgery, or after a hypothyroidism diagnosis, you won't gain weight. This is absolutely wrong and has even been proven by respected research.

Failing to Be a Caring Partner Who Believes You Can and Should Feel Truly Well Again

You can't make the wrong doctor into one who cares, is open-minded, and who is your partner in wellness. So there's a time when it's best to make a decision to move on to a practitioner who is right for you.

Was this page helpful?