What You Need to Know Before Getting Out-Of-Network Care

Choosing an out-of-network provider? Learn how to mitigate the added costs and quality risks. Image © PhotoAlto/Milena Boniek/Getty Images

There are lots of reasons you might go outside of your health insurance provider network to get care. However, getting care out-of-network increases your financial risk as well as your risk for having quality issues with the health care you receive. While you can’t entirely eliminate your increased risk, you can decrease it if you do your homework in advance.

Before you go out-of-network, get a clear understanding of the risks involved and what you can do to manage them. Start by understanding why getting health care out-of-network carries more risk.

Why Getting Care Out-Of-Network Is Financially Risky

You lose the health plan discount.

When your health insurance company accepts a physician, clinic, hospital, or another type of provider into its provider network, it negotiates discounted rates for that provider’s services. When you go out-of-network, you’re not protected by your health plan’s discount. The only negotiated discount you’re going to get is the discount you negotiate for yourself. Since you don’t have high-powered negotiators on staff making sure you get a good deal, you have an increased risk of getting charged too much for your care.

Your share of the cost is higher

Your share of cost is the deductible, copay, or coinsurance you have to pay for any given service. When you go out-of-network, your share of the cost is higher. How much higher it is will depend on what type of health insurance you have.

If your health plan is an HMO or EPO, it may not cover out-of-network care at all. This means you’ll be responsible for paying 100% of the cost of your out-of-network care.

If your health plan is a PPO or POS plan, it may contribute some toward the cost of out-of-network care. However, it won’t pay as large a percentage of the bill as it would have paid had you stayed in the network. For example, you may have a 20% coinsurance for in-network care and a 50% coinsurance for out-of-network care.

Even your deductible may be affected. If your health plan contributes to the cost of out-of-network care, you may discover that you have one deductible for in-network care and another, higher, deductible for out-of-network care.

You can be balance-billed

When you use an in-network provider for covered health plan services, that provider has agreed not to bill you for anything other than the deductible, copay, and coinsurance that your health plan has negotiated.

When you use an out-of-network provider, not only can that provider charge you whatever he wants, he can also bill you for whatever is left over after your health insurance company pays its part (assuming your insurer pays anything at all towards an out-of-network bill). Called balance billing, this can potentially cost you thousands of dollars.

Here’s how it works. You decide to use an out-of-network provider for your heart catheterization. Your PPO has a 50% coinsurance for out-of-network care, so you assume that your health plan will pay half of the cost of your out-of-network care, and you’ll pay the other half. The heart catheterization comes with a bill of $15,000, so you think you’ll owe $7,500, right? Wrong!

Your PPO will look at that $15,000 bill and say something to the effect of “That’s too much. A more reasonable charge for that care is $6,000, so we’re only allowing a $6,000 charge. We’ll pay our half of the reasonable $6,000.” The PPO pays $3,000.

The out-of-network provider doesn't care what your health plan thinks is a reasonable charge. It credits your PPO’s $3,000 payment toward the $15,000 bill and sends you a bill for the balance (that’s why this is called balance billing). You now owe $12,000 rather than the $7,500 you thought you’d owe. 

The ACA requires insurers to count emergency care as in-network, regardless of whether it's received at an in-network facility or not. But there's nothing that prevents the out-of-network doctor or emergency room from balance billing the patient in that case, unless a state has implemented its own balance billing protections.

And there are also concerns about "surprise" balance billing, which occurs when a patient seeks care at an in-network medical facility, but then receives treatment from an ancillary provider (a radiologist or anesthesiologist, for example) who isn't contracted with the patient's insurance company. If you're scheduling an upcoming treatment, it's important to talk with the medical facility in advance to ensure that everyone on your treatment team will be in your insurance network. If that's not the case, or if the hospital can't guarantee that, you'll want to discuss the issue with your insurance company to see if a solution can be reached.

States are increasingly taking action to protect consumers from surprise balance bills. And the federal government requires health plans to count out-of-network services provided at in-network facilities towards the patient's in-network out-of-pocket maximum. But that doesn't prevent the surprise balance bill, and the patient still has to pay it, unless their state has a different solution.

The cap on your out-of-pocket maximum will be higher–or non-existent

Your health insurance policy’s out-of-pocket maximum is designed to protect you from limitless medical costs. It places a cap, or maximum, on the total amount you’ll have to pay each year in deductibles, copays, and coinsurance. For example, if your health plan’s out-of-pocket maximum is $6,600, once you’ve paid a total of $6,600 in deductibles, copays, and coinsurance that year, you can stop paying those cost-sharing charges. Your health plan picks up 100% of the tab for your covered health care costs for the rest of the year.

However, many health plans don’t credit care you get out-of-network toward your out-of-pocket maximum. Since the out-of-pocket maximum may be the only thing standing between you and absolute financial ruin if you develop a costly health condition, choosing to get care outside protecting that out-of-pocket maximum will increase your financial risk. 

Some health plans have a second (higher) out-of-pocket maximum that applies to out-of-network care, but other plans don't cap out-of-network costs at all, meaning that your charges could be unlimited if you go outside your plan's network.

Quality of Care Issues With Out-Of-Network Care

Many people seek care out-of-network because they feel they can get a higher quality of care than their health plan’s in-network providers will provide. While this may or may not be true, be aware that you may lose some quality protections when you go out-of-network.

You may have problems with coordination of your care

Especially in health plans that won’t pay anything for out-of-network care, there are no good systems for the smooth coordination of the care given by an out-of-network provider with the care given by your in-network providers.

Ultimately, the onus is on you to make sure that your in-network doctors know what your out-of-network doctor is doing, and vice versa. You’ll be both the patient and the information conduit between your regular in-network providers and your out-of-network provider. 

Before blithely accepting that the buck stops with you…realize that the buck will never actually stop. You won’t have to step in just once to fill this communication gap. You’ll have to do it each and every time you have an appointment, get a test, have a change in your health, or a change in your treatment plan.

You’re not just bridging the communication gap between your doctors, either; you’ll be doing it between your out-of-network provider and your health plan, also. For example, if your out-of-network cardiologist wants to order a test or treatment that requires ​pre-authorization from your insurance company, you’ll be the one responsible for making sure you get that pre-authorization. If you don’t get the pre-authorization, your health plan can refuse to pay.

You’ll lose health plan screening of providers

Before allowing a health care provider to participate in its provider network, your health plan screens him or her. This may be as simple as checking that the provider's licenses are in good standing or that facilities are accredited by recognized health care accrediting organizations like JCAHCO. However, the credentialing process can be much more complex and detailed than that, providing a service that would be difficult for you to duplicate yourself. Additionally, many health plans have ongoing programs monitoring the quality of care provided to their members by their in-network providers. Providers not measuring up to quality standards risk getting dropped from the network.

When you go out-of-network, you lose the safety net of your health plan’s quality screening and monitoring programs.

You'll lose your health plan's advocacy with providers

If you ever have a problem or a dispute with an in-network provider, your health insurance company can be a powerful advocate on your behalf. Since your health plan represents thousands of customers for that provider, the provider will notice if the health plan throws its mighty weight behind your argument. If the health plan doesn't think the provider is behaving appropriately, it could even drop him or her from its network. Although things rarely progress this far, it's nice to know you have someone with clout on your side.

On the other hand, an out-of-network provider couldn't care less what your health insurance company thinks. Additionally, no matter how egregious the incident that sparked your dispute was, your health insurance company isn't going to waste its time advocating for you with an out-of-network provider it can't influence.

How to Manage the Increased Risks Associated With Out-Of-Network Care

Since you’ll have an important role in making sure you get quality care from your out-of-network provider, study up. These links may help you:

Make sure your out-of-network providers have the records from your in-network providers, and that your in-network providers have the records from your out-of-network providers. Most people will need to get their own medical records. How to Request Your Medical Records.

Coordinating your own care takes meticulous attention to detail. You need to become the world's best expert in your own health care. You are the captain of your health care team, and you need to be up to speed about what each of your team members is doing and why. 

In addition to providing medical records, you need to take your own notes when you get care. Using your own notes, you can give a quick verbal update to your providers about changes in another providers' plans for your care. You should be able to explain why a provider made the changes in your plan of care that he or she made, not just what the changes were. 

Since you’ll be paying for a larger portion of your care when you get that care out-of-network, you need to know what the cost will be before you get the care. Plan on negotiating a discounted rate with your out-of-network provider; you don’t want to pay the “rack rate.” If your health plan contributes toward paying for out-of-network care, ask it what its reasonable and customary rate is for the care you’ll require. These resources will help:

Was this page helpful?

Article Sources